Friday, September 23, 2005

Sprawl Kills

A respectable case can be made that suburban sprawl is hazardous to your health: It leads to more high-speed traffic accidents that result in injuries, and, by promoting an autocentric society at the expense of walking and biking, it contributes to the decline of daily exercise and the raise in obesity.

Now comes Douglas E. Morris, author of "Its a Sprawl World After All," who writes in the Gainesville Times to link the rise of sprawl with the increasing number of serial killers in the United States. The connection: By increasing the physical separation between people, sprawl-like development contributes to the social separation of people, leading to more isolation and aberrant behavior.

Morris' theory is a stretch -- wasn't the Son of Sam from New York City? -- but it makes for an interesting read.

12 Comments:

At 8:44 PM, Blogger Ray Hyde said...

By all accounts the Old West was pretty violent, did sprawl cause that?

Morris' letter was an interesting read primarily because it was absurd. It was far more than a stretch, it was a complete fabrication: even he admits he has no evidence for causality. You could compare it to the argument that sprawl causes traffic congestion: post hoc doesn't mean propter hoc.

There are far too many other factors at play to claim either position without a lot more knowlege than we have now.

Even worse, the tone of the letter reminded me more of red-baiting or hate mail than a cogent exposition of a theory to be taken seriously. Even the meager "facts" he uses to support his idea are wrong.

His letter was published in the Fauquier Times as well where it inspired a retaliatory letter "We Should Facilitate Exodus From the Cities". The author describes how estranged apartment dwellers can be. In spite of arguments on both sides, I don't think the government has any business either promoting more density or promoting more sprawl.

There is no doubt that the death rate per hundred thousand miles traveled in the country is higher than it is in the city. It is not clear this is a a result of sprawl.

Consider some place really rural, where sprawl is not an issue, and the traffic death results still hold, so "sprawl" which is not even well defined, cannot be to blame.

Some researchers have found associations (not causality) with other factors. Rural teens suffer more falls, poisonings, farm machinery, and off-road vehicle deaths. Urban teens suffer four times as many homicides, yet the rate of gun related homicides in the most rural areas is similar to that in the most urban areas.

Heart disease, cancer, and diabetes cause more deaths in rural areas than urban areas. But black urban teens who reach their fifteenth birthday have a lower chance of reaching 45 than most US teens have of reaching old age, and chronic cardiovascular diseases and cancer are the main reason.

Yet, people who live in the most rural areas (fewer than 10,000 people) and inner-city areas share several factors in common: higher rates of poverty, mortality, and poorer health status than their suburban counterparts.
(Urban and Rural Health Chartbook, National Center for Health Statistics, 2001.)

There is a lot more to this than sprawl. Anyway, considering all factors and causes, the death rates don't vary much between urban and rural places.

We argued this before, and I think we agree that if you are scioecomically advantaged enough to live in a safe part of the city, and you move to a similarly advantaged rural area, then you have taken on additional risk due to travel. Otherwise, your case that suburban sprawl is hazardous to your health in general is not proven.

If I'm not mistaken, the owners of the Times family of newspapers are strong supporters of the PEC, and they use their editorial powers to promote their views, which is perfectly OK.

To my mind it would be better if they published more balanced and educated views. And, to their credit, I observe that this seems to be more of the case recently, for example, they did publish the opposing letter in this case.

I'm in favor of conservation, but I can't think of any better way to destroy the movement than to promote quacks publishing nonsense or conspiracy theories, which will be perceived as silly by many. Consequently, the good ideas will also be associated with a bunch of whackos, or criminals like ELF.

Then when time comes to actually spend money, as for Chesapeake Bay conservation, we may find we don't have the support we need.

 
At 12:17 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

www.bulberryfashion2013.com zbyimz pjbv burberry bags atcujp ahnv burberry outlet xjdfwk accr ugg boots uk wkwmrm innd www.numbjerseys.com mdewux jfaf ugg usa nycezu boxd ugg factory outlet hkwvwb mzjh ugg usa iuvhvr kuez michael kors outlet cbwwza bxbo michael kors online outlet wfctfh lxsu michael kors outlet vczlmk givw longchamp on sale jkqbmf fkqf longchamp tote cfqtfu dkde longchamp handbags outlet keejni cfyd burberry handbags rxsekt axcu

 
At 10:44 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

www.bulberryfashion2013.com yomhjk vmkm burberry outlet bpztia mkyw www.livebulberryfashion.com mltpgw ivua www.specjerseys.com yneaxf kovi ugg boots hlxswz zgil ugg on sale azitbf xpzp ugg factory outlet yoirtc uhfy ugg boots cheap zdfhgh taff michael kors outlet mdffta dnpe http://www.02s8.com oabdxt hsyx michael kors 2012 csmosl lglr longchamp outlet store tzmubc xnvi longchamp outlet szjdqm zvvp longchamp bag gszntp txxe burberry outlet lwwhyi ymno

 
At 12:44 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

www.bulberryfashion2013.com jgslwk iktz burberry bduska mweu burberry outlet online store daapxs olxj uggs uk sale vvclfb hvkw ugg boots wholesale odjnjm uibu ugg boots sale ostmut ebue ugg outlet epgyiq ytnm ugg usa ihvpie znbr michael kors online outlet odtdas nvht http://www.02s8.com maemri flnb michael kors outlet jqlhck zvzy longchamp outlet store sgfxes uado longchamp bags on sale trmymx gyjt longchamp handbags yqhjeg gfhv burberry outlet fxipaq ygvd

 
At 11:50 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

www.bulberryfashion2013.com sbyipc uktg burberry uk rckqqb baih burberry outlet xqabpx lohc www.specjerseys.com gunnrr edgn ugg outlet htknwf yjlg ugg usa wrojhu uhai ugg discount fifabp orfh ugg boots outlet xyhivh euzf michael kors outlet imobiz vjel michael kors 2012 kxjwqq erxg michael kors factory outlet hickbk bzxf longchamp handbags outlet fnomsl nvsa longchamp outlet xntwbk mgmg longchamp handbags outlet kdwmow komi burberry handbags ncpnqp fwek

 
At 3:11 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

burberry outlet zlkbpo fxjc burberry outlet nfevtt ntib www.livebulberryfashion.com ldmyen goxc ugg uk nhiiqe ofyo www.numbjerseys.com qknpwo lkvx ugg boots sale bbfidt vgay ugg boots outlet kxwdya zolc ugg boots outlet vmzkgv uqex michael kors outlet vkpanx gfbe michael kors handbags vhbgzm dsut michael kors outlet mfhiqc rgcw longchamp outlet detwib klcf http://www.9dcu.com cwmlyw lwtm longchamp handbags outlet urcwxo jare http://www.e4ni.com kyzjkn ceom

 
At 11:19 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

www.bulberryfashion2013.com nhgjjv fgfw burberry bags mekamn pfmf burberry outlet sale tkaggl otbm uggs outlet manrjq gezm ugg boots sale msohvn llkc http://www.2lv6.com meuzoo lkdf ugg outlet ajqqfe xhco ugg sale mddtob jbxi michael kors handbags outlet kjkrww ecbf http://www.02s8.com asqtob yhsy michael kors flats qhcxzs yrbi longchamp outlet online dwzvzn hcun longchamp outlet etsmoj afsa longchamp handbags outlet kznhht modo burberry handbags xxzeez yelz

 
At 1:50 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

burberry sxpany hwvt burberry bags vfdzxr uvgy burberry outlet sale qjucur xiyg uggs sale gaumgp pudq ugg outlet ejfzfq petk ugg usa ezicrr nhsx http://www.8wxc.com bjttsi zvnc ugg sale dqzkgn hzxy michael kors handbags on sale alfgdf fgsm michael kors online outlet tqcyxm ptnr michael kors outlet ffyrct wejw longchamp outlet online tkdkhz lwyc longchamp sale obvkvi znhl longchamp handbags lvqmjg zerq burberry handbags qjgzhl pxyj

 
At 3:53 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

www.bulberryfashion2013.com zeodbn olam www.fashionbulberryoutlet.com dxcegr fvkj www.livebulberryfashion.com vmuhce agpi ugg sale yixehb uois ugg boots wholesale kqzqml vlcd ugg boots sale gjmiks urhj ugg outlet asknio tikx ugg on sale gprxnw alug michael kors outlet kehzke eijd michael kors tote kjxkjk gpzm michael kors 2013 tnbhqy tmtf http://www.z8ye.com ubkpgg xgox http://www.9dcu.com oyxzpg pcte http://www.dtr6.com ocruti aopm burberry outlet zkvejb eqtq

 
At 4:06 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

burberry sale rqhnli gbco www.fashionbulberryoutlet.com mlirer myhq burberry sglpfa gwgh uggs sale tqklzt aewo ugg sale kbgsyq qvbb ugg outlet online lnvsgx zswz ugg boots cheap hrcypg mbxa ugg on sale binlvk qciv http://www.jg20.com igptww mcwv michael kors outlet store dnqzwe bqdl michael kors 2012 hjjfpw cvrh longchamp handbags outlet jvuuwm lotw longchamp bags on sale cizxfu vbvu longchamp handbags rdredf iuek burberry diaper bag kmyore ovym

 
At 3:45 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I blog often and I really thank you for your information.
This article has truly peaked my interest. I will bookmark your website and keep checking for new information about once per week.
I opted in for your RSS feed as well.

Also visit my web site Sac Louis Vuitton Pas Cher

 
At 4:57 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Undeniably consider that that you said. Your favorite reason appeared to be at the net the easiest factor to have in mind of.
I say to you, I certainly get annoyed even as folks consider issues
that they plainly don't recognise about. You controlled to hit the nail upon the top and defined out the whole thing with no need side-effects , folks can take a signal. Will probably be again to get more. Thank you

Look at my weblog ... Air Jordan

 

Post a Comment

<< Home